‘Preston Patriots’ protest against refugee support and Hebron decisions outside Town Hall
Preston Patriots made an unexpected visit to Town Hall in Preston.
Get involved in the conversation
Cases have been delayed or adjourned because of passengers being collected late or even forgotten
Barristers have warned that cases are routinely being delayed or adjourned because of issues with bringing defendants to court.
Among a series of problems raised by lawyers in recent months are prisoners being collected late or even forgotten with seemingly no accountability when such mistakes are made.
In one instance, a sentencing for historic sexual offences against two victims was unable to go ahead because the defendant was not brought from HMP Preston to Preston Crown Court.
Read more: Office block could become courthouse while essential repairs take place
Both victims attended court to deliver victim impact statements but the defendant, who has a disability, couldn’t be brought to court until a suitable vehicle could be sourced from Lancaster. When the vehicle arrived at HMP Preston, the defendant hadn’t yet been brought from the wing so wasn’t ready to leave.
The two victims, as well as supportive family and friends, had been waiting at the court all day. The sentencing was listed to start at 10.30am and instead, at 2.45pm, was adjourned to another date two months away. One of the victims was unable to attend the new date.
The barrister said: “There seems to be no accountability whatsoever for those entrusted with ensuring defendants are brought to court. The clear evidence is that the companies involved do not employ enough people or have enough vehicles.”
According to the Bar Council, Preston Crown Court received the seventh-highest number of reports from barristers reporting delays. It says research based on reports from barristers across the country has shown the “endemic” and “routine” nature of delays caused by the late delivery of prisoners to court.
Over four months, more than 200 reports were made to the Bar Council – averaging 13 per week – of instances where individuals in custody were brought to court late or not at all.
Barristers said delays are “routine”, describing trials not starting until the afternoon with whole weeks of cases being lost due to the delays, wasting time and resources.
Another barrister in Preston was told a defendant had “refused” to attend his sentencing, when in fact the transportation from HMP Preston to Preston Crown Court had been cancelled. No explanation was given.
The barrister said: “I do not comprehend why the initial information when a defendant has not appeared at court is ‘refusal’. Judges and counsel are now taking this explanation with a pinch of salt owing to the fact that time and time again the real reason appears to be bureaucratic error with an accompanying obfuscation of the error by blaming the defendant.”
On another occasion, a prisoner at HMP Styal was forgotten about, meaning the prison transport service had to go back and get them. Their trial at Preston Crown Court was supposed to start at 10.30am but couldn’t begin until 11.45am with the jury and witnesses left waiting. The same prison was the source of another complaint when a case was delayed for two hours as the defendant was brought to court late with no reason given.
The barrister said: “This is a daily occurrence. Plans cannot be made and continuity of counsel or presence of trial counsel is impossible to achieve when time listings/markings are completely ignored by the prison escort service. It impacts on defendants’ liberty, representation, court sitting days, listings and people’s livelihoods.”
Another barrister at Preston Crown Court said a defendant who was supposed to arrive from HMP Berwyn, in Wrexham, at 10am didn’t arrive at court until 12.30pm, and their case couldn’t be heard until 3.30pm. Again no explanation or warning was given.
HMP Altcourse, in Liverpool, is another to attract frequent complaints with one barrister warning it is so common that the prison refuses to provide estimated arrival times.
The problems aren’t just at the prison’s end as one defendant at Preston Crown Court was left in a van outside for 45 minutes as there were no staff available to move them, meaning their case was heard late.
A quarter of all reports made to the Bar Council said the delay caused by the late delivery of prisoners to court lasted more than five hours, and 34% said they were delayed for between two and 5 hours. Almost half of reports said the delay had a “significant” impact on the smooth running of the case.
The Bar in England and Wales is divided into 6 geographical regions, known as ‘circuits’. Of the 213 reports submitted, 20 were from barristers working in the Northern Circuit.
According to the Ministry of Justice, contractor performance for delivering prisoners to court remains consistently above 99% but researchers at the Bar Council say there is a ‘chasm’ between reported delays and official data. It says the data currently available through Prisoner Escort Custody Service (PECS) does not allow for full and accurate measuring of delays in prisoner delivery.
Nor does official data help untangle the reasons for the delays, which researchers found can occur anywhere along the journey from the prison cell to the dock and may or may not be attributable to the service overseen by PECS.
Sir Brian Leveson, when conducting his independent review of criminal courts, explored the challenges with PECS, which he said are complex and rely on multi-agency communication. Delays were found to not only have a detrimental impact on the timely functioning of court cases but also the wellbeing of all those involved in the case.
Describing their frustration with prison transport services, one Northern Circuit barrister said: “There seems to be no accountability whatsoever for those entrusted with ensuring defendants are brought to court. The clear evidence is that the companies involved do not employ enough people or have enough vehicles.”
The Bar Council is now calling for the government to urgently prioritise the avoidable delays caused by late prisoner delivery and to improve measuring the performance.
Samantha Hillas KC, Leader of the Northern Circuit, said: “The findings in this report provide an accurate snapshot of the long-standing issues barristers on the Northern Circuit face each week. These delays don’t just impact upon defendants: they disrupt proceedings for complainants, witnesses, the family and friends of those involved, judges, barristers, solicitors and court staff.
“These delays are not caused by juries. Rather than focusing on plans to cut access to jury trials, the government should instead ensure that there is cohesion amongst all agencies tasked with preparing prisoners for court and transporting them on time.”
Support Blog Preston: Keep our community reporting going and view the website without any adverts too. Sign up for a membership today.
Stay updated: Keep in touch directly with the latest headlines from Blog Preston, join our WhatsApp channel and subscribe for our twice-a-week email newsletter. Both free and direct to your phone and inbox. Help us report too, by contacting us if you see something we should be reporting on.
Read more: See the latest Preston news and headlines
See us on Google: Set Blog Preston as your preferred source so you don’t miss our stories and see us first when you’re searching
Add Blog Preston as a preferred source on Google
Our petition calling for Preston to have a major city venue again - as the Guild Hall remains closed View collection
Prestonians doing good and lovely things View collection
Food & Drink Scene
176 Articles
All the latest food and drink news in the city View collection
Don’t miss out—get the best of our stories delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday and Wednesday for free. Sign up below for our email newsletter packed with top stories and more.
Please be aware, by subscribing to the Blog Preston newsletter, you’re consenting to your details being stored within our marketing tool Mailchimp, please read their data processing addendum for more details.
Comments are closed.