Cross Keys Inn in Whitechapel is situated in a hilly, remote spot near Beacon Fell, tucked into the countryside and adjoined with a set of holiday homes for those visiting the area – but for those willing to venture out, there is a beautiful bar and restaurant with a function room that is well worth a visit.
The building has a traditional stonework appearance that makes it blend in with the rural surroundings, but inside, it’s a wonderful modern space that has the charm and cosiness of a traditional pub, with more modern fittings, bright airy rooms, and clean and well-maintained decor that speaks to the overall standards of the venue.
It’s also staffed by a very warm and friendly team that made the visit extremely pleasant and accommodating.
Stepping inside, I asked if I could get some food and was given the choice to sit in either the bar area or the dining area. I was given a great deal of freedom and flexibility, before being handed a menu and being able to place orders for drinks.
After being left with the menu, I browsed what was available, and found that there is an extraordinarily wide range of options, from the standard starters and mains, to pizzas, burgers, grilled items, and even a few specialist options that need to be ordered in advance.
I asked a member of the staff what was popular, and I was told that the Steak and Ale Pie (£16.95) was a “legendary dish” on the menu, so I ordered that as a main, along with a Black Pudding Crumpet (£8.95) as a starter.
The starter came out a few minutes after ordering. I was excited to try something new as they mentioned this was a recent addition to the menu, although they always have a black pudding dish on there. And I have to say, the black pudding itself was cooked very well, resulting in a wonderful texture and taste without any hint of charring as can often happen with black pudding.
That said, I wasn’t a huge fan of the crème fraîche combination with the crumpet, though the chives added a nice bit of freshness. There was also a small, solitary piece of apple, heated up and placed on top of the pudding, resulting in a creative combination, but not one that I found particularly appealing. All of the individual elements were pleasant, but I think I would opt for something like the Garlic Mushroom Vol-au-Vents (£7.95) in future.
Moving on to the main, the Steak and Ale Pie came out with an individually prepared pie that was a very generous size, along with a plate of chunky chips, a pot of peas, and some gravy poured over the chips and pie. I was immediately impressed with the portion size, and excited to dig into a perfectly presented pie.
Before remarking on said pie however, I need to give praise to the chips, which were perfectly cooked. As in every chip was golden brown, they all had the perfect soft texture on the inside, and the thickness ensured that even with a loose gravy poured on top, they remained structurally intact and continued to be stunning to the end of the meal. The peas tasted good, but they were clearly there to add colour more than anything else.
Now, the pie itself. Cutting into this crispy, golden-brown pastry, I was very happy to find whole, chunky pieces of steak, which were incredibly tender and tore apart easily with the fork. The sauce inside the pastry was much thicker and richer than the gravy on the plate, but it worked well for the interior of the pie, ensuring it wasn’t soggy, and the pastry held strong.
The pastry itself was incredibly decadent, dripping with butter and flaky, and it provided the perfect vehicle for the steak. Packed and brimming with meat and rich sauce, this was indeed a “legendary dish.”
Upon finishing the pie, I was presented with the dessert menu, and a small chalk board with the specials of the day, but I opted to keep it simple and traditional and go for the Sticky Toffee Pudding for £7.50, and a hot chocolate for £3.50.
The hot chocolate was served in a large mug, piping hot, and had a good froth to it. It was pleasant and tasted like a Cadbury’s hot chocolate, which in all fairness is the gold standard for go-to hot chocs.
But the Sticky Toffee Pudding was exceptional. Served hot, in a large block and drenched in toffee sauce, with a scoop of real vanilla ice cream on the side, with visible vanilla pods, I could tell immediately that this was going to be delightful.
Biting into the pudding, my expectations were met, and the wonderful toasty, darkly sweet, and intense flavors of the dish were spectacular. Paired with the ice cream, the contrast between hot and cold, and the creamy and refined sweetness of the vanilla with the sticky and indulgent sweetness of the toffee were wonderful.
At the end of the meal, I was thoroughly stuffed, completely satisfied, and despite a shaky start with the more experimental starter, I can firmly attest that the Cross Keys Inn knows exactly what it is doing when it comes to traditional British classics. I’m confident there is plenty more on the menu that I would be delighted to indulge in, and I will be making a trip back out on those country roads to get another hearty meal and warm reception.