Judge backs South Ribble Borough Council over sacking chief executive

Posted on - 18th February, 2022 - 3:28pm | Author - | Posted in - Politics, Preston News, South Ribble News
South Ribble Borough Council chief executive Heather McManus
Former South Ribble Borough Council chief executive Heather McManus

An employment tribunal has backed a decision to sack a former South Ribble Borough Council chief executive.


The tribunal vindicated South Ribble Borough Council’s decision to dismiss Heather McManus in July 2020, stating the council followed a ‘fair and reasonable approach’ in reaching its outcome.

An independent internal investigation found ‘significant errors of judgement’ and raised concerns over the treatment of staff.

Read more: South Ribble Borough Council scores high marks in climate change assessment 

Councillor Paul Foster, Leader of South Ribble Borough Council, said: “I’m really pleased that the tribunal has backed our decision, but that is tainted by the fact that we had to devote time and resources to this over the last year when in my view it was wholly unnecessary.

“The independent investigation that looked into the actions of Ms McManus was overwhelming in its conclusions, and the findings were significant and serious, leading the council to decide to dismiss the former chief executive for serious misconduct.

“We can now put this episode behind us and concentrate on delivering the exciting projects for our residents that will benefit people right across the borough.”

Read more: Lancashire County Council highways team ‘well prepared’ for Storms Dudley and Eunice

After the council’s reputation was left in tatters, it received praise for the progress it had made.

The employment tribunal saw Ms McManus bring claims against the council and its leader and deputy leader.

The judge cleared the councillors of any wrongdoing, dismissing any criticism of their actions to suspend Ms McManus and refuting any claims of a ‘witch hunt’ targeted at the former chief executive.

Read more: UCLan academic plays integral role in gaining recognition for a Caribbean Queen

The hearing took place over five days in October and examined evidence from all parties before reaching its decision, issued earlier this week (Tuesday 15 February).

But the judge concluded that Ms McManus was entitled to be dismissed within her contractual rights.

It meant the claimant should have been paid her remaining notice period instead of being sacked with immediate effect.

Read more: UCLan to see five days of lecturer strikes over pay 

Cllr Foster said: “The judgement vindicates what we did because the council was in a period of turmoil and needed strong leadership to put us back on the right track.

“Everyone agreed that dismissing Ms McManus was the right thing to do, and on balance, we felt it was appropriate to take that decision with immediate effect because of the seriousness of the issues identified.

“Since the dismissal, we have made fantastic progress in fixing the governance issues, and a recent Local Government Association (LGA) peer review spoke in glowing terms about the improvements we had made.

“Having to sack the chief executive is something that is not done lightly and shows we will make the tough decisions to do what is best for our residents.”

See what’s happening near you by entering your postcode below or visit InYourArea

Read moreSee the latest Preston news and headlines

Preston in pictures Ring-Billed Gull at Preston Docks, Lancashire, England - August 2015Cuerden Valley Park, PrestonGarden shotStreetBike ridePreston OdeonPreston OdeonUntitled View more Advertisement Subscribe to the newsletter

Sign up below to receive Blog Preston's weekly newsletter. It wings its way into inboxes every Sunday rounding up our best content from the last week and a look ahead to what's happening.

Advertisement News by location

Find news by location, select an area of your choice to be kept up to date with the latest goings on.

Advertisement Categories

Find news by category, select an category of your choice to be kept up to date with the latest goings on.