Family’s plea to dismiss Brockholes Brow killer’s appeal

Posted on - 22nd October, 2018 - 11:46am | Author - | Posted in - Crime, Fishwick, Preston News

Rachel Murphy and Shelby Maher

Rachel Murphy and Shelby Maher

The families of Shelby Maher, 17, and Rachel Murphy, 23, who were killed as they crossed Brockholes Brow, have made a plea to the Attorney General to dismiss the girls’ killer’s appeal against his conviction.


More than 900 people have signed a petition calling for Mohmed Salman Patel’s appeal to be thrown out.

Patel, from Blackburn, was jailed for six years on August 7 after being found guilty of causing Rachel and Shelby’s deaths by dangerous driving.

Throughout two trials, Patel protested his innocence but after hearing evidence he was using his mobile phone minutes before the fatal collision, he was found guilty by the jury at Preston Crown Court.

In a further blow to the families, Patel has launched an appeal against his conviction and sentence.

Mohmed Salman Patel arrives at Preston Crown Court Pic: SWNS
Mohmed Salman Patel arrives at Preston Crown Court, Lancs. PIC: SWNS

In response to the news, Rachel and Shelby’s families launched a petition urging the Attorney general to dismiss the appeal, which has attracted 920 signatures and messages of support for the families.

One supporter said: “What is the purpose of law, if people who blatantly disregard it, are subsequently entitled to appeal? The driver did not graze somebody’s knee. He ended somebody’s life. He ended their family’s journey in life.

“He knew the law. He chose to ignore it. The consequences were irreparable for the families of the victims. I can not comprehend why he believes he deserves leniency. Unbelievable.”

Read more: This is exactly what happened in the Brockholes Brow crash

Another said: “I’m signing because I agree that the sentence given was far too lenient for the crime. If anything it should be increased. Two young girls had their lives cut drastically short because of his negligent behaviour and this is something that their families will have to live with for the rest of their lives.”

A family spokesman said: “On behalf of the late Shelby Maher (17), the family would like to make a plea to the Attorney General to dismiss the appeal made by Mohmed Salman Patel of his conviction and sentence for the killing of Miss Shelby Maher (17) and Miss Rachel Murphy (23)  by texting while driving, and to review his unduly lenient sentence of six years on which the court ruled that Mr Patel will only serve three years in effect 1.5 years for each life taken.

The petition can be found at Petitions 24.

Preston in pictures The Station, Preston. 1539Adelphi quarter , preston , 23.06.2022St Walburge's Church, preston 23.06.2022Former Tithebarn pub and Preston Bus StationHarris Museum and Art GalleryRed telephone boxesRed telephone box on Market StreetPreston 2022 View more Advertisement Subscribe to the newsletter

Sign up below to receive Blog Preston's weekly newsletter. It wings its way into inboxes every Sunday rounding up our best content from the last week and a look ahead to what's happening.

Advertisement News by location

Find news by location, select an area of your choice to be kept up to date with the latest goings on.

Advertisement Categories

Find news by category, select an category of your choice to be kept up to date with the latest goings on.